ChatGPT

SUBSTACK.COM WINS

beehiiv.com6/10

substack.com8/10

“⚔️ Razor thin. substack.com barely edges it on ChatGPT.”

Gemini

BEEHIIV.COM WINS

beehiiv.com8/10

substack.com7/10

“🏎️ Substack walked so beehiiv could run, and darling, beehiiv just lapped the competition.”

Claude

SUBSTACK.COM WINS

beehiiv.com7/10

substack.com8/10

“🐝 Beehiiv showed up with slick vibes and creator-friendly features, but Substack's already been living rent-free in the newsletter consciousness since 2017—hard to dethrone a king when you're still explaining what you do at dinner parties.”

Perplexity

BEEHIIV.COM WINS

beehiiv.com8/10

substack.com6/10

“"According to 14 sources—" 😤 beehiiv.com takes Perplexity by a hair. substack.com is right there.”

Ghost Report Card

Why substack.com is getting ghosted

beehiiv.com 7373 substack.com

Key Findings

Missing llms.txt

beehiiv.com has a llms.txt file telling AI how to represent them. substack.com doesn't — AI is guessing.

Low Web Presence

substack.com has very low web presence (13/100). AI may not have enough data to form opinions.

Unlock with Loamly

AI Platform Mentions

See which AI platforms mention your brand and how often

Competitor Citation Gap

Discover which sources competitors get cited from that you don't

Content Recommendations

AI-generated content actions to boost your visibility score

Monthly Visibility Trend

Track how your Ghost Score changes over time across all platforms

Get the Full AI Visibility Audit

50 prompts. 4 platforms. Verbatim AI responses + 90-day action plan. From $299.

Track beehiiv.com

Get monthly Ghost Score updates for beehiiv.com — free, no account needed.

Both are hanging on — barely.

want more?

See your full AI visibility score across ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity. Free, instant, no signup.

Check YOUR AI visibility (free)

Scores estimated from search signals, domain authority & AI training data coverage.