“💥 ChatGPT wrote a love letter to both. Refused to pick.”
Gemini
SUBSTACK.COM WINS
buttondown email6/10
substack.com9/10
“🏆 Substack might be a chaotic colossus, but at least it's *the* chaotic colossus everyone's talking about, while Buttondown is still waiting for its mom to subscribe.”
Claude
SUBSTACK.COM WINS
buttondown email7/10
substack.com8/10
“🎭 Buttondown is the reliable Honda Civic of newsletters while Substack is the Tesla that convinced everyone they're now a publisher—one's honest about what it is, the other's built an empire on creator delusion.”
Perplexity
BUTTONDOWN EMAIL WINS
buttondown email7/10
substack.com4/10
“🏆 Perplexity didn't even hesitate. buttondown email > substack.com, no debate.”
Buttondown Email is fading from AI.
want more?
See your full AI visibility score across ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity. Free, instant, no signup.